
U. S. History I - 11.4 - Podcast - Big Business - Thomas Woods
Scott Clifton
Overview
This video challenges the conventional view of 19th-century big business, arguing against the idea that all major industrialists were 'robber barons' and that government intervention is always necessary to protect the public. It distinguishes between market entrepreneurs, who succeed by providing value, and political entrepreneurs, who rely on government favors. The discussion uses historical examples like railroads, oil, and steel to illustrate how government subsidies can distort incentives and lead to inefficiency, contrasting this with the success of entrepreneurs who operated without such aid. A significant portion of the video debunks the concept of predatory pricing as a viable strategy for monopolies, explaining its practical difficulties and economic irrationality, and explores how market forces themselves can prevent such abuses.
Save this permanently with flashcards, quizzes, and AI chat
Chapters
- The common perception of 19th-century businessmen as 'wicked exploiters' needing government regulation is a simplistic and unhelpful 'cartoonish' view.
- Historian Bert Folsom distinguishes between 'market entrepreneurs' who succeed by creating value for consumers and 'political entrepreneurs' who gain advantages through government privileges like subsidies and tariffs.
- The 'myth of the robber barons' suggests that many successful industrialists were actually innovators who improved society's well-being.
- Government assistance to railroads, such as subsidized loans and free land grants, created perverse incentives.
- Land grants encouraged railroads to build inefficient, winding tracks through difficult terrain to maximize land acquisition, rather than the most direct and cost-effective routes.
- This system benefited political entrepreneurs by rewarding them for acquiring government land, not for efficient construction or serving the public's transportation needs.
- James J. Hill's Great Northern Railroad is a counter-example of a successful enterprise built without government assistance.
- Hill's focus on efficiency and profitability led to a robust railroad that turned a profit even when others went bankrupt.
- He actively invested in developing the communities along his route, demonstrating how market entrepreneurs can foster growth by serving their customers' needs.
- John D. Rockefeller's Standard Oil significantly lowered the cost of kerosene, improving living standards by providing an affordable alternative to whale oil.
- His success was driven by ruthless efficiency and cost-cutting, including developing 300 products from refinery waste.
- The historical accusation of Rockefeller engaging in predatory pricing to monopolize the market has been largely debunked; he primarily acquired competitors at fair prices.
- Andrew Carnegie's steel production, particularly at the Homestead plant, was extraordinarily efficient, producing significantly more steel with fewer workers than European competitors.
- Despite favoring steel tariffs (a political favor), Carnegie's core business was driven by efficiency and dramatic price reductions in steel rails.
- The price of steel rails fell drastically, far outpacing general price level declines, indicating significant productivity gains.
- Predatory pricing, the strategy of selling below cost to eliminate competition and then raising prices, is largely considered a myth by economists.
- It's practically difficult to execute because consumers stock up during low prices, new competitors can enter with low-cost assets, and the strategy is enormously expensive.
- Large firms attempting predatory pricing incur massive losses on their dominant market share, often exceeding any potential gains from eliminating a small competitor.
- Even in chain store scenarios, the potential profits from predatory pricing are often too small to justify a large firm risking its entire capital.
- The market itself has incentives to prevent predatory pricing; suppliers have an interest in maintaining competition among their buyers.
- Mechanisms like minimum resale price maintenance (though now illegal) could have been used by suppliers to prevent retailers from engaging in predatory pricing.
- Herbert Dow of Dow Chemical developed an inexpensive way to produce bromine and faced threats from a German cartel that dominated the European market.
- The cartel retaliated by dumping bromine in the U.S. at extremely low prices to drive Dow out of business.
- Dow cleverly countered by buying up the cartel's cheap U.S. bromine and reselling it in Europe, ultimately forcing the cartel to agree to market division.
Key takeaways
- The historical narrative of 'robber barons' often overlooks the genuine value and innovation provided by big businesses.
- Government intervention, through subsidies and regulations, can create perverse incentives leading to economic inefficiency.
- Market entrepreneurs who focus on efficiency, cost-cutting, and meeting consumer needs are often more successful and beneficial to society than those relying on political favors.
- Predatory pricing is an economically irrational and practically difficult strategy for firms to successfully implement and sustain.
- Market forces and the self-interest of various players within the economy can act as natural checks against monopolistic abuses.
- True wealth creation often comes from increased efficiency that lowers costs for everyone, not from redistributive political actions.
- Historical examples demonstrate that determined entrepreneurs can overcome even powerful cartels and market manipulation.
Key terms
Test your understanding
- How does the concept of a 'market entrepreneur' differ from a 'political entrepreneur,' and why is this distinction important for understanding 19th-century business?
- Explain how government subsidies, such as land grants to railroads, could unintentionally incentivize inefficient business practices.
- What are the primary economic and practical reasons why predatory pricing is considered a largely ineffective strategy for establishing monopolies?
- Describe how market forces, beyond direct government regulation, can act to prevent or counteract potential monopolistic abuses by large firms.
- How did entrepreneurs like James J. Hill, John D. Rockefeller, and Herbert Dow demonstrate success through efficiency and market adaptation, often in contrast to businesses receiving government aid?