Forces at Key Points
R TOP T + mg → centre BOTTOM T − mg = $mv^{2}$/R SIDE v = √(3gR) Min Speeds (string) Top: √(gR) Side: √(3gR) Bottom: √(5gR) Tb − Tt = 6mg Min Speeds (rod) Top: 0 Bottom: √(4gR) = 2√(gR) v (tangential)String vs. Rod — Key Distinction
A string can only pull (tensile force). Minimum tension = 0 at the top ⟹ v_top ≥ √(gR).
A rigid rod can push (compressive) or pull. At the top with v = 0: rod pushes inward, providing centripetal force. So v_top,min = 0.
Tension Difference Formula
This is a powerful check formula — always valid for any speed (not just minimum).