Part of ME-04 — Work, Energy & Power

Trap MCQ Analysis

by Notetube Official303 words4 views

Trap 1: Rod vs. String in Vertical Circular Motion

The Trap: "Minimum speed at the top for a ball in a vertical circle" — applying the string result (gR\sqrt{gR}) to a rigid rod.

Correct Logic:

  • String: Cannot push → T ≥ 0 → minimum T = 0 → vtopv_{top} = gR\sqrt{gR}
  • Rod: CAN push → v can be zero at top (rod provides centripetal force) → vtopv_{top} = 0

Distractor options often give "gR\sqrt{gR} for both" (wrong) or "5gR\sqrt{5gR} and 4gR\sqrt{4gR}" which are the bottom speeds, not top speeds.

Trap 2: KE in Perfectly Inelastic Collision

The Trap: Assuming KE = 0 after perfectly inelastic collision (thinking "all KE is lost").

Correct Logic: Momentum is conserved. If ptotalp_{total} ≠ 0, then vfv_f ≠ 0, so KEafterKE_{after} ≠ 0. Only 50% of KE is lost (for equal masses).

Trap 3: Forgetting Friction in Work-Energy Theorem

The Trap: Treating only the applied force's work as WnetW_{net}.

Correct Logic: WnetW_{net} = WallW_{all} forces = WappliedW_{applied} + WfrictionW_{friction} + WgravityW_{gravity} + WnormalW_{normal}. On rough surfaces, WfrictionW_{friction} = −μₖNd is always negative and must be included.

Trap 4: Work by Normal Force

The Trap: Assuming normal force always does zero work.

Correct Logic: On a horizontal surface, WNW_N = 0 (N vertical, d horizontal). But on an inclined surface, if normal force has a component along displacement, it can do work. However, N is always perpendicular to the surface and displacement is along the surface, so WNW_N = 0 always on any incline. (This trap is the reverse — students sometimes think N does work on an incline.)

Trap 5: KE vs Momentum After Doubling Speed

The Trap: "Doubling speed doubles KE" — wrong.

Correct: Doubling speed → KE quadruples (KE ∝ v2v^{2}). Doubling speed → momentum doubles (pvp \propto v).

Like these notes? Save your own copy and start studying with NoteTube's AI tools.

Sign up free to clone these notes