Part of PH-01 — Dual Nature of Radiation & Matter

Misconceptions

by Notetube Official421 words4 views
#MisconceptionWhy It's WrongCorrect Statement
1"Increasing intensity of light always causes emission"Intensity only increases photon count; each photon has fixed energy hν; if hν < φ, no photon can eject an electronEmission requires ν ≥ ν_{0}; intensity determines photocurrent but not whether emission occurs
2"Stopping potential V0V_{0} increases with intensity"V0V_{0} = (hν − φ)/e has no intensity termV0V_{0} depends only on frequency; intensity affects only saturation current
3"Photons travel at different speeds depending on their energy"Common confusion with particles — heavier particles are slowerAll photons travel at c = 3×1083 \times 10^{8} m/s in vacuum regardless of energy or frequency
4"A photon can be 'broken into smaller pieces' to provide cumulative energy"Photon interaction is all-or-nothing; one photon → one electron (in standard photoelectric effect)Energy transfer is quantised; you can't store photon energy and wait for enough to accumulate
5"de Broglie waves are physical waves that carry energy through space"Matter waves are probability amplitude waves, not mechanical oscillationsThe de Broglie wavelength predicts diffraction/interference patterns; it does not mean the electron is physically oscillating
6"Electrons have no wave nature because they have mass"This was the pre-1924 view. Davisson-Germer disproved itEvery particle with momentum p has wavelength λ = h/p; confirmed experimentally
7"λ = 1.227/√V nm works for all charged particles"Derived using m = m_e and q = e specificallyValid ONLY for electrons; protons, alpha particles require λ = h/√(2mqV) with their specific m and q
8"Threshold frequency is the same for all metals"Different metals have different work functions φ; ν_{0} = φ/h variesEach metal has a unique work function and therefore a unique threshold frequency
9"The photoelectric effect and Compton effect are the same"Both involve photon-electron interaction, but mechanisms differPhotoelectric effect: photon absorbed, electron ejected (complete transfer). Compton: photon scatters (partial transfer), electron recoils with deflected photon
10"Higher frequency light is always more intense than lower frequency light"Frequency and intensity are independent: intensity = (photons/s) × hνA dim UV source can have lower intensity than a bright red source; frequency and intensity are independent quantities

Like these notes? Save your own copy and start studying with NoteTube's AI tools.

Sign up free to clone these notes