| # | Misconception | Truth |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Adiabatic means constant temperature." | Adiabatic means Q = 0 (no heat exchange), not = 0. Temperature changes significantly — expansion cools, compression heats. |
| 2 | "In adiabatic expansion, = 0." | = −W in adiabatic process. Expansion (W > 0) means < 0, so internal energy and temperature decrease. |
| 3 | "Carnot efficiency can be calculated in Celsius." | Carnot formula η = 1 − / requires absolute (kelvin) temperatures. Using Celsius gives completely wrong answers. |
| 4 | "A 100% efficient heat engine violates the First Law." | A 100% efficient engine would violate the Second Law (Kelvin-Planck), not the First. Energy is still conserved if W = and = 0. |
| 5 | "v_mp is the maximum possible molecular speed." | v_mp is the most probable speed (peak of Maxwell distribution), not the maximum. Molecules can have any speed up to infinity (theoretically). |
| 6 | "v_rms = v_avg because both are averages." | v_rms ≠ v_avg. v_rms = √(3RT/M), v_avg = √(8RT/πM). v_rms > v_avg > v_mp always. |
| 7 | "COP of a refrigerator is always less than 1." | COP of a refrigerator = /( − ) and can be much greater than 1. A fridge cooling from 300 K to 270 K has COP = 270/30 = 9. |
| 8 | "The work done in a thermodynamic cycle is always zero." | Work per cycle = area enclosed by the cycle on the PV diagram. For a clockwise cycle (engine), W > 0. Zero work would mean a cycle with zero area (degenerate). |
| 9 | "Entropy decreases in a refrigerator because it makes things colder." | The total entropy of the system + surroundings always increases. The refrigerator decreases entropy of the cold reservoir by increasing it more in the hot reservoir. |
| 10 | "Internal energy of a gas depends on pressure and volume." | For an ideal gas, U = (f/2)nRT depends only on temperature. At the same temperature, two states with different P and V have the same U. |
Part of THERM-01 — Thermodynamics & Kinetic Theory of Gases
Misconceptions: 10 Entries
Like these notes? Save your own copy and start studying with NoteTube's AI tools.
Sign up free to clone these notes