| Feature | Markovnikov Addition | Anti-Markovnikov (Kharasch) |
|---|---|---|
| Conditions | No peroxide; acidic/ionic | HBr + organic peroxide (ROOR) ONLY |
| Mechanism | Electrophilic (ionic) | Free radical (chain reaction) |
| Which HX works? | HF, HCl, HBr, HI, | ONLY HBr (not HCl, not HI) |
| First species to add | (electrophile) | Br• (radical) |
| Site of H addition | C with more H atoms | C with fewer H atoms |
| Intermediate | More stable carbocation | More stable carbon radical |
| Product from propene | 2-Bromopropane CC(Br)C | 1-Bromopropane CCCBr |
| Driving force | Carbocation stability | Radical stability |
| Why not HCl + peroxide? | N/A | Cl• + alkene is endothermic — chain fails |
| Why not HI + peroxide? | N/A | I• too reactive — premature termination |
Reaction Schemes
Markovnikov (propene + HBr, no peroxide):
CC=C --[HBr, no peroxide]--> CC(Br)C (2-bromopropane)
Mechanism: → secondary carbocation (C-2) → attacks C-2
Anti-Markovnikov (propene + HBr + ROOR):
CC=C --[HBr, ROOR]--> CCCBr (1-bromopropane)
Mechanism: ROOR → RO• → Br• → adds to C-1 (less substituted) → 2° radical at C-2 → H from HBr → 1-bromopropane