Part of PC-02 — Atomic Structure

Comparison Note: Bohr Model vs Quantum Mechanical Model

by Notetube Official193 words4 views
FeatureBohr ModelQuantum Mechanical Model
Electron trajectoryFixed circular orbitsNo definite trajectory (probability clouds)
PositionPrecisely known (orbit radius r_n)Described by probability density ψ^{2}
BasisPostulates + classical mechanicsSchrödinger wave equation
Energy (H atom)E_n = −13.6/n2n^{2} eV ✓Same formula (exact for H)
Works forHydrogen and hydrogen-like ions onlyAll atoms
Handles multi-electronNo (ignores e-e repulsion)Yes (approximations available)
Angular momentumL = nh/2π (always quantized, never zero)L = √[l(l+1)]ℏ (can be zero for s orbitals!)
Explains Zeeman effect?Partially (normal)Yes (fully)
InconsistencyViolates Heisenberg principleFully consistent
Orbital conceptOrbits (defined paths)Orbitals (probability regions)
Magnetic propertiesCannot explainExplained by spin and orbital quantum numbers

Key Insight: Bohr's energy formula E_n = −13.6Z2Z^{2}/n2n^{2} is still used for NEET calculations in hydrogen-like atoms, even though the orbital model replaces fixed orbits with probability distributions.

Like these notes? Save your own copy and start studying with NoteTube's AI tools.

Sign up free to clone these notes